Thursday, 23 January 2025

Herm Bust of George Dance by Charles Rossi and an anonymous putative bust of James Gibbs and Some Notes on the use of the Herm Bust in the 18th and Early 19th Centuries.



A brief look at the use of Herm type busts in the 18th and early 19th centuries.

A herma (Ancient Greek: ἑρμῆς, plural ἑρμαῖ hermai), commonly herm in English, is a sculpture with a head and perhaps a torso above a plain, usually squared lower section.

This post follows on from my post on the use of the classical eared socle by Nollekens and some of his contemporaries.

see - https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/11/some-earlier-nollekens-busts.html


This form of bust was much used in antiquity and revived in the neo classical period of the mid to late 18th century. 

The Engraving of the self portrait bust by Thomas Banks (below) is one of the first uses of this form of bust in England in the 18th Century.


The Soane Museum Plaster Bust of George Dance.

 Charles Rossi 1762 - 1839.


Soane Museum.

This post was prompted by a notification from the Soane Museum which appeared in my inbox this morning.

Another reason for posting is that it resembles a bust supposedly of James Gibbs in the Radcliff Camera, Oxford (designed by Gibbs) see the images below.





They say - 
"There is little surviving correspondence from Dance and almost nothing to reveal his thoughts on architecture. Moreover, few of his buildings survive. Yet his legacy is notable, thanks largely to his surviving drawings at the Soane Museum. These were the last great addition to Soane’s collection, on 18 November 1836, just weeks before Soane died. Soane’s accounts show that he paid Dance’s son, Sir Charles Webb Dance, £500 for the drawings collection. Along too came a handsome cabinet, known as ‘The Shrine’ which had been made to contain the drawings. The Shrine can be admired in the North Drawing Room at the Soane Museum and still contains the Dance collection, comprising an invaluable record of the work of George Dance the Younger, a towering figure in architectural history".

..................

I first came across Rossi when investigating the terracotta  sculptures of the Coades at Lambeth.


For Rossi and the Coade manufactury see Bob Speels website





........................

The Marble Bust of George Dance.

Charles Rossi (1762 - 1839).

Royal Academy.

Notes below from the Royal Academy website.


This bust of the architect George Dance RA was gifted to the Royal Academy by its maker Charles Rossi. Made in 1827, it was first exhibited at the British Institution Exhibition of that year. Rossi and Dance had been fellow Academicians for many years, and Rossi also sat to Dance for his pencil portrait in 1798 which was part of the series of sketches made of Members of the Academy which Dance produced over many years. Dance had died two years before Rossi carved this bust, and it had a particular relevance for the Royal Academy as Dance was the last to die of the founding Academicians.



Charles Rossi, was the son of an Italian immigrant, he was born in Nottingham in 1762. He was apprenticed to the Italian sculptor G. B. Locatelli, completing his apprenticeship in 1781. 

That same year Rossi entered the Royal Academy Schools, where he won two medals. During this time, he began exhibiting at the Royal Academy. In 1785 Rossi was awarded a travelling scholarship which enabled him to live in Rome between 1786 and 1788.


Once back in England, Rossi worked briefly for the Derby china works (1788) and the clockmaker Vulialmy (1789) before establishing himself as a sculptor. The two large lions he sculpted for the west watergate of Somerset House (then the home of the RA) in 1790 served notice of his talent. In the 1790s he produced large works with the mason-sculptor John Bingley and executed church commissions, graduating to major commissions, including four government commissions for memorials to military heroes of the French wars for St Paul’s Cathedral. His work also incorporated portrait busts (two of which are in the RA collection) and decorative work for architectural projects.


After his return to London, he formed a partnership with a mason-sculptor called J. Bingley, and drawing on his early training in terra cotta, made a variety of terra cotta and stone statues (much later he worked on terra cotta with J. H. Bubb). 

He flourished in the 1790s, winning commissions for architectural sculpture on important buildings, and designing four monuments in St Paul's. He was elected ARA in 1798, and RA in 1802. Over the course of a long working career, he managed to produce 16 offspring, by two wives, and of these three at least became sculptors - Henry Rossi in London, Frederick Rossi, and Charles Rossi, who became a monumental mason and went to live in Barbados. Rossi himself stayed in London, lodging for a period with the well-known painter Benjamin Hayden, in a modest house off Lisson Grove in Marylebone.

 

Other artists were often critical of Rossi’s work, but he was highly successful – in 1797 he was appointed as sculptor to the Prince of Wales and subsequently as sculptor-in-ordinary to George IV and to William IV. Rossi’s 1804 bust of the prince regent was widely admired, and he later executed a frieze of The Seasons at Buckingham Palace. In 1802 he was elected as a Member of the Royal Academy, where he continued to exhibit until 1834. Rossi died at his London home in 1839.


 https://www.royalacademy.org.uk/art-artists/work-of-art/bust-of-george-dance-r-a




...............................

Rossi by Dance.

Soane Museum.




.......................


The bust of  George Dance illustrated here set me thinking about another herm bust which has been troubling me for since travelling to Oxford to research the portrait busts at the University.


......................


The Putative Plaster Bust of James Gibbs (1682 - 1754).

H 56 x W 33 x D 23 cm

Royal Institute of British Architects.

included in drawings catalogue, 1871.

Another version of this bust is on the staircase in the Radcliff Camera, Oxford.

I cannot accept that this is a bust of James Gibbs the architect.


https://www.ribapix.com/James-Gibbs_RIBA138774


https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/james-gibbs-16821754-275389
































................................


The Radcliff Camera Putative Marble Bust of James Gibbs.


Inscribed Presented by TG Bucknall Estcourt MDCCCXLV.


Photographs below taken by the author.








































Comparing the bust of Gibbs in the Radcliff Camera with the putative marble bust of Gibbs.


As can be seen the shape of the nose is entirely different. and the prominent mole is not in evidence.







...........................


The Marble Bust of James Gibbs (1682 - 1754). 

Michael Rybrack.

1726.

now in the Victoria and Albert Museum.

Photograph by the author.

It is very difficult to discern any similarities with the Radcliff Camera plaster bust pictured above.



see my post - https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2015/07/a-marble-bust-of-james-gibbs.html

For Gordon Balderston's very informative Essay on the Busts of Gibbs and Alexander Pope by Rysbrack - pub. Georgian Group Journal, 2001 see -

Rysbrack's Busts of James Gibbs and Alexander Pope for Henrietta Street -

https://georgiangroup.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/GGJ_2001_01-BALDERSTON.pdf







Gibbs commissioned this bust, and it remained in his ownership until his death, another bust of Gibbs (below), also by Rysbrack, belonging to the Bodleian Library, Oxford, and now shown in the Radcliffe Camera, depicts the sitter in a more classicising mode, without a wig, and bare-chested. 


Gibbs and Rysbrack lived near one another on the Harley estate north of Oxford Street in London. They collaborated together on a number of projects, notably monuments in Westminster Abbey (designed by Gibbs, and executed by Rysbrack), and garden ornaments and sculpture for the grounds at Stowe House, Buckinghamshire.


George Vertue suggests that the working relationship between Gibbs and Rysbrack was 'not altogether happy' Gibbs employed Rysbrack 'for his own advantage not for encouragement' and speaks of 'extravagant exactions' and goes on to say 'an unreasonable griping usage to a most ingenious artist. (in his way) far more merit than Gibbs ever will be. Mr of'. Obviously Vertue was not a great fan of Mr Gibbs.


Vertue in 1723 refers to three portraits of Gibbs a 'modeld' bust suggesting a terracotta a marble bust and basso relievo with a wig on. The terracotta and basso relievo are missing.

 

In 1723 Vertue refers to a terracotta bust ' Mr Jacamo or James. Gibbs Architect born at Aberdeen. ano. 1863. his head a Moddeld by Mr Rysbrack extreamly like him a bald head. cut in marble from that another basso relievo. with a wigg on.

 

Provenance: Presented to the Church of St Martin's in the Field by William Boore an Antique dealer and silver merchant of The Strand in 1885.

Acquired by the V and A Museum in 1989.

.............


Engraved profile of James Gibbs by Bernard Baron, 

1736.


Headpiece from an unidentified publication.
10.1 x 13.0 cms 

Engraving from British Museum.
 

It is tempting to suggest that this is an engraving of the missing basso relieve by Rysbrack described by George Vertue in 1723.






....


The Radcliff Camera, Oxford  bust of James Gibbs by Michael Rysbrack.

1723.









Given its location it is very difficult to obtain good photographs of the Rysbrack Gibbs Bust.

Here are a couple of my rather feeble attempts.

Less obvious in the black and white images is the surprisingly poor quality of the marble flecked with dark inclusions











................


No sign of the mole on the left side proper of his nose!





























........................

James Gibbs.

John Michael Williams.

NPG.







Signed below his right shoulder in black: J. Williams Pinx., the J rather faint.

On the top bar of the stretcher a stencil 24 H, and in ink on a paper on the back of the centre bar: Portrait of Gibbs, the Architect, from Mr. Sharpe's Collection/I brought [edited: originally bought] from his Seat at Brockley Hill, Middx, on/the demolition of the House in [paper torn] 1830./Thomas Sharpe Smith/21 Nov. 18(40] [edited: originally (44)- the last two figures indistinct.


.........................



Portrait of James Gibbs.

John Michael Williams.

H 89.5 x W 69 cm

Bodleian Library.

Acquired prior to 1760.




.........................

James Gibbs.

Mezzotint After Wiliams.

James Mcardle.


James MacArdell (1729-1765) was born in Cow Lane, Dublin around 1729. He studied mezzotint-engraving under John Brooks. When Brooks moved to London about 1746, MacArdell and other pupils followed. 

He opened a print shop at the Golden Head Henrietta Street, Covent Garden, where in 1753 he published six views of Dublin and was a prolific engraver. He was said to be the favourite engraver of Joshua Reynolds.

MacArdell died on 2 June 1765, in his fifty-seventh year, and was buried in the churchyard at Hampstead, where a stone bore an inscription to his memory



............


James Gibbs.

McArdell after Hogarth.

Mezzotint.

British Museum.












........................



James Gibbs.

Engraving Bernard Baron after William Hogarth.
1747.

Image courtesy Metropolitan Museum, New York.












Another possible portrait of Gibbs.

Bartholomew Dandridge.

.....................


Whilst making comparisons of portrait paintings, engravings and busts is very dangerous.


Here is my suggestion for a possible candidate for the sitter. Whilst lacking the mole and having washed his hair, this bust is much closer to the busts at the RIBA and the Radcliff Camera!


Charles Hutton (1737–1823).

Aged 85.

Marble bust.

Sebastian Gahagan (c.1778–1832) or Francis Chantry.

Gahagan 


There are conflicting entries in the Biographical Dictionary of British Sculptors.... pub Yale 2009.

Both entries under Gahagan and Chantry have the bust of Hutton at Newcastle.

in The Literary & Philosophical Society of Newcastle.


Charles Hutton (1737–1823) | Art UK


NPG website says - "Marble bust by Sebastian Gahagan, with loose drapery (see NPG 5783). Newcastle Literary & Philosophical Society. 

Commissioned by subscription for the sitter who bequeathed it to the Society. 

Exhibited RA 1822 (1034). Engraved J. Thomson 1823 from a drawing by W. Derby (European Mag.). The plaster model was completed in 1821 and the marble bust presented to the sitter on 21 September 1822. Casts were obtained by ‘many of Dr. Hutton’s friends, and still continue to be supplied by the sculptor’ (Gentleman's Magazine, XCIII, 1823, I, p 232).



































https://www.british-history.ac.uk/no-series/newcastle-historical-account/pp461-486


Medallion by Wyon after the bust.

Aged 85 - as the inscription on the socle of the bust.




Engraving of the Medallion of Hutton by Wyon



.................

The Stipple Engraving of the Bust of Hutton by J Thompson.

1822



Charles Hutton was buried in the family vault at Charlton in Kent. During the last year of his life a group of his friends set up a fund to pay to have a marble bust made of him. It was executed by the sculptor Sebastian Gahagan. The subscription exceeded the amount necessary, and a medal was also produced, engraved by Benjamin Wyon, showing Hutton’s head on one side and emblems representing his discoveries about the force of gunpowder, and the density of the earth on the other

........................



Christopher Hewetson (d.1798) and his Herm Busts.

Hewetson left England in 17 and worked in Rome for the rest of his life.

Most of his busts followed the standard form but he made several using the Herm type.


Angelica Kauffman (1741 - 1807).


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/02/hewetson-in-rome-part-23.html



..................


Hewetson's bust of Gavin Hamilton - 1784.


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/02/hewetson-sculptor-in-rome-part-13.html




.........................


Hewetson's Bust of Liebnitz,

c. 1784.

https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/03/hewetson-part-35-leibnitz.html

The Plaster cast Gottingen University



........................


Andrew Stuart (1725 - 1801).

 Keeper of the Signet at the Signet Library, Edinburgh.

Christopher Hewetson

Rome c. 1789.


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/02/hewetson-sculptor-in-rome-part-13.html





...........................


The Volpatto / Hewetson Double Herm of Mengs and Azara.


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/02/the-busts-of-mengs-and-azara.html





.....................................


Thomas Banks (1735 - 1805).

A Self Portrait.

Marble Herm Bust.

1791.

see my post https://english18thcenturyportraitsculpture.blogspot.com/2019/01/bust-of-roubiliac-or-not.html

This bust has disappeared. I would dearly like to find it.

https://www.royalacademy.org.uk/art-artists/work-of-art/self-portrait-bust-of-thomas-banks-r-a





.........................


Another early 19th Century Herm bust - Edward Thurlow, Baron Thurlow.

John Charles Felix Rossi.

Artificial stone bust, 

1809.

20 in. (508 mm) high.

Purchased, 1979.

Primary Collection

NPG 5238

https://www.npg.org.uk/collections/search/portrait/mw06346/Edward-Thurlow-Baron-Thurlow?LinkID=mp07496&role=art&rNo=1&mode=test





............................


Some Herm Bust Sculpted by Francis Leggatt Chantry (1781-1842).

Probably the successor to Nollekens in terms of quality and quantity

By no means exhaustive.


....................

Richard Porson (1759–1808).

Marble.

1808.

Francis Leggatt Chantrey (1781–1841).

Trinity College, University of Cambridge.

Image courtesy artuk website.


Richard Porson (1759–1808) | Art UK



.............................

Sir HC Englefield.

Francis Leggat Chantry.


Inscribed left side: Chantrey/Sculptor/1818; rear: Sir H. C. Englefield, Bart.

https://www.clevelandart.org/art/1978.22




Walker King (1752–1827).

Francis Leggatt Chantrey (1781–1841).

Marble.

1820.

Corpus Christi College, University of Oxford.

Image courtesy artuk website.

Walker King (1752–1827) | Art UK








...........................

Another bust of Walker King Bishop of Rochester (1751 - 1827).

Sir Francis Legatt Chantrey (1781-1842).

1821.

Marble.

52.71 x 32.7 x 24.13 cm).

Los Angeles County Museum of Art.

https://collections.lacma.org/node/227102



........................

Sir Joseph Banks.

Francis Leggat Chantry.

Marble 1818/19.

Image courtesy artuk website

Sir Joseph Banks (1743–1820) | Art UK




....................

James Watt (1736 - 1819).

Francis Leggat Chantry.

Marble Herm Bust.

52.3cms

Text and image below courtesy National Galleries of Scotland.

https://www.nationalgalleries.org/art-and-artists/4071



James Watt achieved lasting fame as an engineer and scientist with his improvement of Newcomen's steam engine. After years of experimentation, in 1775 he entered into a partnership with businessman Matthew Boulton to produce the improved engine. Their success led to the opening of a purpose-built steam engine factory in 1796, after which Watt gradually withdrew from active participation. By 1814, when he commissioned his bust from Chantrey, Watt was a national – if reluctant – celebrity. Following its exhibition in 1815 at the Royal Academy,




...............................


William Howley, Bishop of London (1766-1848).

Marble bust.

 58.4 cm x 34.3 cm x 26.7 cm 

dated 1821.

Francis Leggatt Chantrey.

Courtesy of the Paul Mellon Collection, Yale Centre for British Art.



...........................






................................

Bishop Shute Barrington (1734 - 1826).

Marble.

1825.

Inscribed on the back CHANTREY, SC. / 1825.

Francis Leggat Chantry.

Image courtesy artuk website

Bishop Shute Barrington (1734–1826) | Art UK




.........................


A Couple of Herm Busts by Samuel Joseph (1791 - 1850).

A sculptor who deserves much greater recognition.


...............

Professor Dugald Stewart, 1753 - 1828. Philosopher.

Samuel Joseph (1791 - 1850).

National Galleries of Scotland.

https://www.nationalgalleries.org/art-and-artists/3879



...................

 Robert Stevenson (1772–1850).

Samuel Joseph (1791–1850).

Marble.

1820's.

Northern Lighthouse Board.

Image courtesy artuk website

https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/robert-stevenson-17721850-262879



...........................


Sir Humphrey Davy.

Samuel Joseph.

1822.

Royal Institution.


https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/sir-humphry-davy-17781829-281709/search/2025--actor:joseph-samuel-17911850/page/3/view_as/grid



.............................

Herm bust of Maréchal Jean-de-Dieu Soult, Duke of Dalmatia (1769-1851).

  Jean-Antoine Houdon (Versailles, 1741 - Paris, 1828).

1813.

     Marble.       

 Height 49cm.


Signed and dated 'houdon, f. 1813'.

 

Image courtesy website of the Daniel Katz Gallery, London














Tuesday, 21 January 2025

Roubiliac's small lay figure.

 



John Wragg, Greek St, Soho, London 1777, 1784, 25 Denmark St, Soho 1789-1793, 10 Tottenham Court Road 1799-1801, 2 London St, Fitzroy Square 1802. Carver and lay figure maker.

 

John Wragg (?c.1737-1804 or later) is presumably the ‘Mr Wragg’, carver and lay figure maker, who advertised from Greek St in 1777 (Daily Advertiser 5 April 1777). He took part in the Westminster election from this address in 1784 (DEFM). As John Wragg, lay figure maker, he was listed in Andrews’s directory at 25 Denmark St in 1789 and 1790. John Wragg features in Holden’s directory as a figure maker in 1799 and as a lay figure maker in 1802, without an entry in 1805. He took out insurance as a figure maker from 10 Tottenham Court Road, on the terrace opposite London St, on 24 June 1801 (Sun Fire Office policy registers, 419/718808). It is likely that he can be identified with the ‘eminent lay figure maker’, age 67, who benefited from galvanic treatment for a paralytic disorder (Charles Henry Wilkinson, Elements of Galvanism, 1804, p.448, accessed through Google Book Search).

 

A small lay figure once belonging to Roubiliac (Museum of London) was repaired by John Wragg in 1793, as can be seen from his interesting letter from 25 Denmark St to the then owner, Richard French at Derby (information from Beatrice Behlen, Museum of London, June 2012, with thanks to Jane Munro).

 

John Wragg features in the 3rd Earl of Egremont’s London and Petworth bills as supplying a lay figure with moveable joints, 1799-1800, perhaps for use by one of the artists working at Petworth (West Sussex Record Office: Petworth House Archives, PHA/8064).

Information above lifted from Jacob Simon's - British artists' suppliers, 1650-1950 prepared for the National Portrait Gallerie's website -


 https://www.npg.org.uk/collections/research/programmes/directory-of-suppliers/suppliers-w/









........................

The Museum of London has a lay figure used by Louis François Roubiliac in the 18th century for his drawing and sculpting classes. According to the museum’s catalogue.


 “The figure is articulated and can adopt a variety of poses. It has a skeleton of bronze overlaid with cork, horsehair, wool and an outer covering of silk stockinette. With a carved and painted wooden head that may be used as both male or female, the model has two sets of accompanying sets of clothes - one male and one female”.


https://www.londonmuseum.org.uk/collections/v/object-287369/figure-lay-figure/

Height 76 cms.













Thursday, 16 January 2025

Is this a bust Horace Mann by Prince Hoare?

 


Post in preparation - Continuing with the loose theme of Strawberry Hill.

A Beautiful Mid 18th Century Terracotta Bust with Milan dealer Walter Padovani.

Terracotta; height 51.5 cm.

They say circa 1749 . 

https://www.walterpadovani.com/portfolio-item/prince-hoareportrait-of-sir-horace-mann/

The provenance is given as Private Collection! Discovered by Dr Silvia Davoli, Head Curator at Strawberry Hill.

Suggested as a Portrait of Sir Horace Mann (1706 - 1786).

by Prince Hoare (b. Eye? Cambridge, 1711 - Bath, 1769).

I remain to be convinced that is either a portrait of Horace Mann or by Prince Hoare!

I don't believe from the evidence available that Prince Hoare was capable of making such a fine bust.

The portraits below of Horace Mann and his brother Galfridus (both illustrated below) depict men with fairly pronounced Roman noses. the bust illustrated here has a fairly obvious cleft chin not visible in the Astley portrait.

https://www.walterpadovani.com/portfolio-item/prince-hoareportrait-of-sir-horace-mann/

It is very dangerous to make comparisons but I will try and make the case for a mis attribution and maybe some suggestions for the sitter and sculptor.

Cerainly the cleft chin is missing on the portrait of Horace Mann by Astly

.........................

For Mann and Horace Walpole see -

https://societyhistorycollecting.org/news-and-events/in-focus-the-grand-tour-the-two-horaces-and-the-court-of-florence-1740-1786-24-march-24-july-2022-2/

............................

To me this bust poses a few questions!

If not Horace Mann - who??

If not sculpted by Prince Hoare - by whom??

Horace Mann was a great letter writer - in particular he corresponded with Horace Walpole, if he had sat for a portrait bust it is unlikely that he would not have mentioned it. see -

 https://libsvcs-1.its.yale.edu/hwcorrespondence/browse.asp?type=Letters&ns=1751


Was it made in Italy as suggested by the current owners?

Was the sculptor English or perhaps French or Italian?

There are no other terracotta busts by Prince Hoare to compare it with!

If it is possible to analyse it would be useful to know where the clay was obtained from.   

The style of the socle/support with a very thick prop is unlike that of most English busts of the period.

Is it hollow? I suspect that it is solid unless the base is open. - it would need somewhere for the air to escape during firing.


It is dangerous again to make generalisations but the terracotta busts made by Netherland sculptors tended to be solid and frequently cracked in the firing - 

Michael Rysbrack's terracotta busts were filled after firing and then painted - those of French sculptors such as Roubiliac were hollow and of a fairly even thin thickness - which was far less likely to crack in the firing and therefor didn't need painting.

I cannot claim any expertise on French or Italian sculptors.


......................

I have already written at some length about Prince Hoare and his more talented assistant Joseph Plura- who probably did most of the work. see - 


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/the-busts-of-gratiana-davenport-by.html


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/beau-nash-statue-in-pump-rooms-bath-by.html


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/beau-nash-bust-by-prince-hoare.html


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/bust-of-ralph-allen-by-prince-hoare_14.html


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/bust-of-ralph-allen-by-prince-hoare.html


..................

Much of the info on the lives and careers of the Hoare Brothers below is culled from

Evelyn Newby - The Hoares of Bath -History of Bath Research Group.


https://historyofbath.org/images/BathHistory/Vol%2001%20-%2004.%20Newby%20-%20The%20Hoares%20of%20Bath.pdf



Prince Hoare - Vertue states that he was 'educated' under Peter Scheemakers.

He went to Italy in about 1742.


By January 1749 he had made an admirable copy of a relief of Antinous belonging to Cardinal Albani who thought him very clever and anxious to succeed. 

From Florence in August 1749 he thanked Albani for his introduction to Horace Mann .....

He copied a bust of Cicero in the Uffizi and was aking a copy of Ganymede for Lewis Monson Watson (Walpole Cores. 20. 86 26 Aug. 1749


Vertue next mentions Prince as the latter returns from Rome 'where he had been to make his studyes about 7 or 8 years', and records his return in January of 1750  (Vertue 3. 152).

But so far the only definite record of him in Italy is in a letter from yet another British Resident in Florence, Sir Horace Mann. In this letter, dated 26 August 1749, Mann is writing to Horace Walpole and damns Prince Hoare with faint praise:

"Hoare the sculptor I have had in my house is to accompany him [Mann's secretary, returning to England] ... I rather wish he may fall into good business in England. He is very clever in copying but I have seen nothing original of his doing. 

Had he application equal to his skill, I believe he could make a figure at least in England, where sculpture is not at any great pitch". 


A bust of Plautilla signed and dated P. HOARE Ft. FLOR:AE MDCCIL and copied from an antique bust in the Uffizi is currently in the Royal Crescent Hotel, Bath UK. It illustrates that he was a proficient copyist but to me appears to be a bit of a pot boiler


Vertue described him as 'a tall handsome and agreeable person somewhat skilled in music'.

The lack of application hinted at in Mann's letter to Walpole is corroborated in passages from letters written by William Pitt to Richard Grenville. Prince had been commissioned to design andcarve a monument to the memory of Captain Thomas Grenville, brother to Richard, who had been killed in action at sea in 1747. The first letter, dated 26 November 1752 from Bath, mentions that work is proceeding apace on the clay model for the statue, the figure promising "to be a very good one'. The second letter, also from Bath. (this is probably the same address).


Evelyn Newby suggests that he was more indolent than his brother (the very successful William Hoare) by nature, and without the financial need to work too seriously to establish himself, was already living in some style in the south wing of Ralph Allen's town house, now 2 North Parade Passage, moving to Abbey Green in 1766".




Prince Hoare's name does not appear in the Bath Mineral Waters Hospital Minutes until May 1758, when he was elected one of the Governors. 

The previous year, his bust of Ralph Allen had been presented by Dr. Warburton, Allen's nephew-in-law, the gift being recorded in the Minutes for 27 April 1757. 

Soon after returning from Italy and settling in Bath, Prince had married well. The Gentleman's Magazine in the list of marriages for 1751 included 'Mr Prince Hoar [sic] a celebrated statuary at Bath - to Miss Coulthurst of Melksham, Wilts, £6,000' . 

The Bath Journal further endorses his happy choice, 'the beginning of last week was married Mr. Hoare an eminent statuary, to Miss Coulthurst of Melksham an agreeable young lady with a handsome fortune', and Prince describes himself as 'gentleman' in the marriage register for 26 May 1751.


Bath Chronicle - 1st November 1770 - Notices: Mauge & Lancashire, successors to Mr Prince Hoare, statuary (& his principal workmen for many yrs), now trading at same yard in monuments, chimney pieces, works in marble, wood & stone.

.................

Joseph Plura - The Assistant to Prince Hoare.


Giuseppe Plura probably trained in Turin at the Carlo Emanuelle III Sculpture Academy and may have completed his training in Paris.

He emigrated to England and by 1749 had settled in Bath where he was known as Joseph. He appears to have begun his career there as an assistant of Prince Hoare and is said to have been responsible for carving the statue of Beau Nash in the Pump Room in 1752.

 Coincidentally, Prince Hoare was in Italy in 1749 and may possibly have encouraged Plura to come to Bath. The Hoare and Plura family remained linked into the next century. 

 In 1747 Plura had taken on a commission in Madrid to teach the son of King Fernando VI about sculpture. 

In 1748 however he had a disagreement with the contractor who had employed him to teach the prince, reputed because he was not getting paid and he subsequently left Spain.

 He is next recorded in 1750 in Bath, England where he was married to Mary Ford (1733–1825), the 17-year-old daughter of John Ford (1711–1767), the master mason for whom he was working under the employ of Prince Hoare (1711–1769). (check this - when was Ford employed by Prince Hoare).


.................................


Horatio Mann - Diplomat; 1732, travelled to Naples for his health; by 1737, he was assistant to Charles Fane, British resident in Florence whose duties he took over in 1740; remained British representative in Florence for the rest of his life; awarded a baronetcy in 1755. 

British visitors to Florence recorded his kindness and generous hospitality; he is remembered particularly for extensive correspondence with Horace Walpole, a distant relation.


https://www.walterpadovani.com/


https://www.walterpadovani.com/portfolio-item/prince-hoareportrait-of-sir-horace-mann/



https://www.walterpadovani.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/scheda_WP_Hoare_ENG.pdf






































































.................................

I'm not sure whether this is a serious suggestion.

If nothing else the hairstyle and clothing are similar - this might date the bust to 1730's - 1740's.

Could it be a bust of the young Bonnie Prince Charlie??

Portrait of Prince Charles Edward, the 'Young Pretender'; (1720 - 88) bust in profile to right, wearing his hair dressed as a tie-wig, a richly laced coat, and the ribbon of the Garter.

Giles Hussey (1710 - 88).

Hussey was working in Rome from 1733 - 37.

It appears that he sat to Hussey twice once in 1734 and again in 1737.

Red chalk

British Museum
















........................



The Portraits of  Horace Mann and his brother Galfridus.

John Astley





...................

Galfridus Mann.

John Astley (1724 -87)

Label on frame: "Galfridus Mann 1750 (John Astley)".

In a contemporary gilt Italian frame as displayed at Strawberry Hill.

Date from Catalog of the classic contents of Strawberry Hill collected by Horace Walpole: 1752.

Provenance

Strawberry Hill sale, 18 May 1842, twenty-first day's sale, lot 42, together with its pair (6 gns to J.P. Bevan). Lord Hastings; Sotheby's, 1 February 1950, lot 71 (£280 to Agnew) with Thomas, Agnew & Sons.






.....................


Horace Mann in the Blue suit on the Left

By Thomas Patch (1725 - 82).

c. 1763 - 65.












.........................


Thomas Patch.

Royal Albert Memorial Museum & Art Gallery.

Queen Street, Exeter, Devon.







Self Portrait of Thomas Patch, (not Horace Mann).

The Duomo at Florence in the background.

One of a series of 25 Caricature by Thomas Patch.


The engraving  annotated by Edward Hawkins, keeper (1826-60) of the Department of Antiquities, British Museum, which Department he had joined in 1825, after an earlier career as a banker. The British Museum purchased his collection of English medals from him on his retirement in 1860





............................................

Plautilla.

Copy of the original

Marble bust.

65.5 cm

Prince Hoare.

 Signed and dated P: HOARE F: FLOR: AE MDCCIL;

 inscribed on waisted socle: PLAVTILLA

Provenance - Anonymous sale, Christie's, 3 July 1985, Lot 252.


Royal Crescent Hotel, Bath.

Image here from the Paul Mellon Photographic Archive.






..................................


Could it be an early bust by Joseph Nollekens and not by Prince Hoare?

There are three possible candidates for the terracotta bust dating from Nollekens stay in Italy of 1761 until 1770.


Nollekens’ master was Peter Scheemakers who he was assistant to for four years and worked as a journey man for a further three years before going to Rome.

Prince Hoare was also an assistant of Scheemakers, he left Rome in 1749, after a sojourn of at least seven years.

1. 1764. Prince Edward Augustus - Marble at Windsor Castle. I have dismissed this - Edward does not have the cleft chin.




2. Noted 9 July 1764. John Richards of North House, Horndean. Hants (Ingamells) Martin Journals - a bust by Nollekens that he thought very like. disappeared

3. 1764. Sir John Wodehouse Bt (Ingamells) He was also painted by Pompeo Batoni in 1764 - disappeared

..............................


Ralph Allen.

Prince Hoare.

dated 1764.


The Bust of  Ralph Allen presented to the Guild Hall Bath on 29 October 1822

By Prince Hoare (the artist and playwright 1755 - 1834) (nephew of the4 Sculptor)

BC/6/9/1/1/23 | Archives and Local Studies Catalogue


















..........................

The Marble Bust of Ralph Allen.

Recently Acquired by the Holburne Museum, Bath.


https://www.facebook.com/photo/?fbid=727347952740893&set=introducing-ralph-allen-1693-1764-whose-marble-bust-has-recently-been-acquired-b



I posted some time ago on the busts and sculptures by Prince Hoare see - etc.

To my eye there is a similarity in the treatment of the flesh in the portrait busts except for that of Jerry Pearce.

I suspect that it was perhaps carved in Hoares workshop by his long term assistant Joseph Plura or another less skilled carver.


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/18th-to-mid-19th-century-sculpture-in.html


see also

https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/08/bust-of-ralph-allen-by-prince-hoare.html







Jerry Pearce.

Supposedly sculpted by Prince Hoare.

I suspect that it was perhaps carved in Hoare's workshop by his long term assistant Joseph Plura.
Harrogate.

....................................




..........................


The Plaster Bust of Jerry Pearce.

Formerly at the Bath Mineral Hospital - missing presumed stolen.









...............................


Sir John Henderson, 5th Baronet of Fordell.

Christopher Hewetson.

1770's.

 Terracotta.

 Museo de la Real Academia Bellas Artes San Fernando, Madrid.

 From the Captured English Ship The Westmorland.