Tuesday, 29 April 2025

A Bust of an Unidentified man depicted as Trajan by Roubiliac at Goodwood House.

 


Some notes

Post under construction

 The Marble Bust derived from an Antique Original of Trajan at Goodwood,

The Anima Dannata Marble Bust after Bernini,

and the Bust of Milo of Croton after Pierre Puget at Blenheim Palace.

All three unsigned busts here proposed as by Louis Francois Roubiliac (1702 Lyon - London 1762).

It appears that he was working in England from 1730.

It has been suggested to me that Joseph Wilton also used a similar socle but I can find no evidence that he used the same model. 

Roubiliac, uses the same socle on 14 different busts known to be from his workshop, as those socles on the three unsigned busts illustrated here.

It is difficult to gauge when he first used this form of socle - possibly as early as 1746 (on the Mary Okeover bust?) but more likely in the 1750's.

5 busts drawn by Nollekens at the Roubiliac posthumous sale use this type of socle.
...........................

The Roubiliac Socle.

I have put together a more detailed post on the use of the form of socle illustrated here, on a group of busts by Roubiliac see -



....................



It is serendipity that this post coincides with the notification for the conference to take place at the V and A - Sculpture between Britain and Italy, 1728–1854. 16 - 17th May, 2025.




In July1752, Roubiliac travelled with the portrait painters Thomas Hudson and Arthur Pond for a very  brief visit to Rome.

As they were travelling to Italy they met Joshua Reynolds at Mont Cenis who was returning from Rome - they met up with him again in Paris on their return journey and they returned to London together Reynolds arrived back in London on 16 October. George Vertue states ' their tour of Italy very quick and their stay very little' that they were in Rome 'only long enough to say that they have seen Rome'. Vertue 3. 162. but the dates suggest that they were in Ital from July until early October -

Roubiliac is later said to have exclaimed to Reynolds that the sculpture of Bernini made his own look ‘meagre and starved, as if made of nothing but tobacco pipes’.


Certainly the busts of the Anima Dannata and Milo of Croton (if one accepts the  attribution to him!) illustrated here show his admiration for Bernini, Puget and the Baroque.

................................


The Goodwood Statuary Marble Bust.

On a Socle of Nero Portoro Marble.

suggested here as perhaps by Roubiliac given the evidence of the Roubiliac type socle.

Height 25".

A possible candidate for this bust is A Caesar - Lot 78, 4th Day of the Roubiliac posthumous sale of Saturday 15th May 1762.


This superb bust has obviously suffered some wear over the years, particularly with some serious abrasions to the nose and the loss of ribbons on the back of the neck, but overall it is in very good condition.

It has been in a damp position in the past and this has allowed the colonisation of a small amount of lichen on the surface. 

The bust has lost most of its original polish, possibly because of previous exposure to the weather but I believe a very gentle clean would improve the appearance of it immensely.

I sincerely hope that no one attacks the surface or uses modern waxes.


The current owner of Goodwood House is Charles Gordon - Lennox, 11th Duke of Richmond.

I am very grateful to everyone at Goodwood for making me so welcome and for facilitating the photography for this post. 

In particular I would like to thank Richard Pailthorpe and Clemmie de la Poer Beresford. 


Of tangential interest see -

J. Kenworthy-Browne, ‘The Duke of Richmond's Gallery in Whitehall’ in The British Art Journal, XX no.1, 2009, pp. 40-49.















































....................



The genesis of this post me from a request by an acquaintance in 2022 to identify the sculptor and provenance of a superb marble bust of the Anima Dannata (Damned Soul) after the original by Bernini purchased in France and illustrated below, which had previously been attributed to Joseph Wilton - the owner had thought that it might have come from Wilton House where it was sold in the dispersal sale - (Christie's, Wilton House, Wilton House, A Selected Portion of the Collection of Ancient Marbles formed by Thomas 8th Earl of Pembroke, July 3rd, 1961). This was disproved when I visited Wilton to photograph the Roubiliac busts and saw the terracottas after Bernini which are in the cloisters at Wilton.


This bust of the Anima Dannata appeared at auction at Christie's 7 December 2023.

Height 22 in. (56 cm.) overall, on a socle of Nero Portoro marble - The Nero Portoro marble quarry is  in Portovenere which is an island in La Spezia province, Liguria Region, Northern Italy.


At the time nothing came of my researches and I put the subject to one side. When visiting Wilton in order to photograph their Roubiliac busts I discovered a terracotta version of the Anima Dannata and its female companion on brackets in the Cloister at Wilton but although similar it was unrelated to this bust.

This pair of busts had been at Wilton House since the mid 18th Century and appear in  A Description of the Antiquities and Curiosities in Wilton-House by James Kennedy of  1769. page 101 -

 "Two bustos one representing TORMENT the other CONTENTMENT". - I should have spotted this!!








........................


A similar recent request to identify the sculptor of another very fine marble bust with a very similar socle, which immediately reminded me of the Roubiliac busts of on the monument in the Church at Tittleshall, Norfolk which I had recently photographed and which then led me to the comparison of the socles of mid 18th century portrait busts.

The monument at Tittleshall, Norfolk was put up and inscribed by Charles Atkinson fl. 1750 - 70, with busts by Roubiliac of Thomas Coke, 1st Earl of Leicester (1759) and the Countess.

Tangentially - Roubiliac uses the same form of the outer drapery on the bust of the Earl of Leicester as his busts of Charles I at the Courtauld and the Fordham Marble bust of Shakespeare now in the Folger Library Washington DC. USA.


I put what I had discovered in relation to the Roubiliac type socles in a recent post -

 https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2025/03/louis-francois-roubiliac-joseph-wilton.html



Whilst putting together this post, a trawl through the photographs in the Paul Mellon Photographic Archive led me to the very fine Goodwood marble bust illustrated here.







At this stage of the researches into this wonderful bust it is difficult to put a name to the sitter, but rather than a bust of Trajan it is possibly a portrait of an Englishmand epicterd as  the Emperor Trajan.

The bust is certainly derived from the antique busts of Trajan. Marcus Ulpius Nerva Traianus, commonly known as Trajan - Traiano in Italian  (18 September 53 – 8 August 117). 


The 18th century historian Edward Gibbon popularized the notion of the Five Good Emperors, of which Trajan was the second. He was succeeded by Hadrian.

Although the concept of the Five Good Emperors is a later invention, and being “good” was from the senatorial perspective: an emperor was good if he respected and yielded power to the senate. 


"Trajan was ambitious of fame; and as long as mankind shall continue to bestow more liberal applause on their destroyers than on their benefactors, the thirst of military glory will ever be the vice of the most exalted characters. The praises of Alexander, transmitted by a succession of poets and historians, had kindled a dangerous emulation in the mind of Trajan. Like him, the Roman emperor undertook an expedition against the nations of the east, but he lamented with a sigh that his advanced age scarcely left him any hopes of equalling the renown of the son of Philip. Yet the success of Trajan, however transient, was rapid and specious. The degenerate Parthians, broken by intestine discord, fled before his arms. He descended the river Tigris in triumph, from the mountains of Armenia to the Persian gulf. He enjoyed the honour of being the first, as he was the last, of the Roman generals, who ever navigated that remote sea. His fleets ravished the coasts of Arabia; and Trajan vainly flattered himself that he was approaching towards the confines of India. Every day the astonished senate received the intelligence of new names and new nations that acknowledged his sway. They were informed that the kings of Bosphorus, Colchos, Iberia, Albania, Osrhœne, and even the Parthian monarch himself, had accepted their diadems from the hands of the emperor; that the independent tribes of the Median and Carduchian hills had implored his protection; and that the rich countries of Armenia, Mesopotamia, and Assyria, were reduced into the state of provinces. But the death of Trajan soon clouded the splendid prospect; and it was justly to be dreaded that so many distant nations would throw off the unaccustomed yoke, when they were no longer restrained by the powerful hand which had imposed it"


This marble version is perhaps derived by that in the Capitoline Museum in Rome or the one in the Braccio Nuova in the Vatican Museum, Rome.

There are numerous versions of his bust. Most show him bareheaded with a sort of pudding bowl haircut but some show him with the laurel crown such as that in the Munich Glyptothek.

For a selection of the bareheaded busts see -


There are two very good versions in the archaeological Museum in Venice and a version was recently sold at Christies.


...................




The Marble Bust of Milo of Croton after Pierre Puget (1620 - 94) at Blenheim Palace.

Here suggest as by Roubiliac given the form of the socle.

I am very grateful to Carmen Alvarez Collections and Conservation Manager of Blenheim for providing the photographs and information regarding this bust.













Literature (not exhaustive) -

H. Furst, "Seventeenth century art at Burlington House", Apollo, XXVII, 1938, p. 119.

K. Herding, Pierre Puget: das bildnerische Werke, Berlin, 1970, fig. 195 and p. 201.

F. Souchal, French Sculptors of the 17th and 18th Centuries: The Reign of Louis XIV, 1977, Vol. 3, no. 200, pp. 196-197.

K. Herding, Pierre Puget: architecte, sculpteur, peintre et dessinateur sous Louis XIV, avec un catalogue raisonné, Paris, 2017 (forthcoming), no. SC 23, copies partielles no. 11

......................


Two Plaster Busts of Sir Thomas Bodley at Oxford.

taken from the stone bust in the Bodleian Library.

Included here to ullustrate the of the use of the Roubiliac type socle.

The stone bust in the Bodleian Library with the two plaster versions on either side.

Apart from the obvious what makes these plaster busts most interesting is the use of the Roubiliac socle and the extension of the trunk of the original stone bust.

I would suggest that these two plaster busts are 18th century and had been adapted by Roubiliac.

and either cast in his workshop or in the Hyde Park Corner workshop of John Cheere.




 

The centre photograph which was taken by the author is of the stone bust in the Bodleian Library.

This bust has in the past attributed to Nicholas Stone - I beg to differ and would suggest Isaac James as a more likely candidate.


I am very grateful to Dr Martin Kauffman, Head of Early and Rare Collections, and Tolkien Curator of Medieval Manuscripts at the Bodleian for allowing me permission to use these photographs of this remarkable bust for the blog.

 I am also truly grateful to Dana Josephson for suggesting the project and for assisting me with the access and photography at the Bodleian Library and the other 18th century busts at the University of Oxford..

On the left the Bodleian plaster and on the right the plaster version at Merton College.

 see my previous posts -

 http://english18thcenturyportraitsculpture.blogspot.com/2017/11/stone-bust-of-sir-thomas-bodley-in.html

 http://english18thcenturyportraitsculpture.blogspot.com/2017/11/update-sir-thomas-bodley-monument.html







.........................



Some more old Black and White Photographs of 18th Century English Sculpture.


Recently I have returned to accessing the Conway Library which is available online and which has been an invaluable but flawed resource (some attributions need updating) for old black and white photographs of 18th century sculpture for me, but is also a unique resource for images of sculpture and architecture of all periods.




This lead me to  many further photographs of the works of Joseph Wilton (1722 - 1803) and is the best visual overview of his career currently available until I can find time to make an  in depth study myself or someone else does it.

Wilton was certainly one of the pre eminent sculptors of the eighteenth century but his busts in the main use an oval (in plan) turned socle.