Thursday, 23 January 2025

Herm Bust of George Dance by Charles Rossi and an anonymous putative bust of James Gibbs.



Plaster Bust of George Dance.

 Charles Rossi 1762 - 1839.

in the Soane Museum.

This post was prompted by a notification from the Soane Museum which appeared in my inbox this morning.

Another reason for posting is that it resembles a bust supposedly of James Gibbs in the Radcliff Camera, Oxford (designed by Gibbs) see the images below.





They say - 
"There is little surviving correspondence from Dance and almost nothing to reveal his thoughts on architecture. Moreover, few of his buildings survive. Yet his legacy is notable, thanks largely to his surviving drawings at the Soane Museum. These were the last great addition to Soane’s collection, on 18 November 1836, just weeks before Soane died. Soane’s accounts show that he paid Dance’s son, Sir Charles Webb Dance, £500 for the drawings collection. Along too came a handsome cabinet, known as ‘The Shrine’ which had been made to contain the drawings. The Shrine can be admired in the North Drawing Room at the Soane Museum and still contains the Dance collection, comprising an invaluable record of the work of George Dance the Younger, a towering figure in architectural history".

..................

I first came across Rossi when investigating the terracotta  sculptures of the Coades at Lambeth.


For Rossi and the Coade manufactury see Bob Speels website





........................

The Marble Bust of George Dance.

Charles Rossi (1762 - 1839).

Royal Academy.

Notes below from the Royal Academy website.


This bust of the architect George Dance RA was gifted to the Royal Academy by its maker Charles Rossi. Made in 1827, it was first exhibited at the British Institution Exhibition of that year. Rossi and Dance had been fellow Academicians for many years, and Rossi also sat to Dance for his pencil portrait in 1798 which was part of the series of sketches made of Members of the Academy which Dance produced over many years. Dance had died two years before Rossi carved this bust, and it had a particular relevance for the Royal Academy as Dance was the last to die of the founding Academicians.



Charles Rossi, was the son of an Italian immigrant, he was born in Nottingham in 1762. He was apprenticed to the Italian sculptor G. B. Locatelli, completing his apprenticeship in 1781. 

That same year Rossi entered the Royal Academy Schools, where he won two medals. During this time, he began exhibiting at the Royal Academy. In 1785 Rossi was awarded a travelling scholarship which enabled him to live in Rome between 1786 and 1788.


Once back in England, Rossi worked briefly for the Derby china works (1788) and the clockmaker Vulialmy (1789) before establishing himself as a sculptor. The two large lions he sculpted for the west watergate of Somerset House (then the home of the RA) in 1790 served notice of his talent. In the 1790s he produced large works with the mason-sculptor John Bingley and executed church commissions, graduating to major commissions, including four government commissions for memorials to military heroes of the French wars for St Paul’s Cathedral. His work also incorporated portrait busts (two of which are in the RA collection) and decorative work for architectural projects.


After his return to London, he formed a partnership with a mason-sculptor called J. Bingley, and drawing on his early training in terra cotta, made a variety of terra cotta and stone statues (much later he worked on terra cotta with J. H. Bubb). 

He flourished in the 1790s, winning commissions for architectural sculpture on important buildings, and designing four monuments in St Paul's. He was elected ARA in 1798, and RA in 1802. Over the course of a long working career, he managed to produce 16 offspring, by two wives, and of these three at least became sculptors - Henry Rossi in London, Frederick Rossi, and Charles Rossi, who became a monumental mason and went to live in Barbados. Rossi himself stayed in London, lodging for a period with the well-known painter Benjamin Hayden, in a modest house off Lisson Grove in Marylebone.

 

Other artists were often critical of Rossi’s work, but he was highly successful – in 1797 he was appointed as sculptor to the Prince of Wales and subsequently as sculptor-in-ordinary to George IV and to William IV. Rossi’s 1804 bust of the prince regent was widely admired, and he later executed a frieze of The Seasons at Buckingham Palace. In 1802 he was elected as a Member of the Royal Academy, where he continued to exhibit until 1834. Rossi died at his London home in 1839.


 https://www.royalacademy.org.uk/art-artists/work-of-art/bust-of-george-dance-r-a




...............................

Rossi by Dance.

Soane Museum.




.......................


The bust of  George Dance illustrated here set me thinking about another herm bust which has been troubling me for since travelling to Oxford to research the portrait busts at the University.


......................


The Putative Plaster Bust of James Gibbs (1682 - 1754).

H 56 x W 33 x D 23 cm

Royal Institute of British Architects.

included in drawings catalogue, 1871.

Another version of this bust is on the staircase in the Radcliff Camera, Oxford.

I cannot accept that this is a bust of James Gibbs the architect.


https://www.ribapix.com/James-Gibbs_RIBA138774


https://artuk.org/discover/artworks/james-gibbs-16821754-275389
































................................


The Radcliff Camera Putative Marble Bust of James Gibbs.


Inscribed Presented by TG Bucknall Estcourt MDCCCXLV.


Photographs below taken by the author.








































Comparing the bust of Gibbs in the Radcliff Camera with the putative marble bust of Gibbs.


As can be seen the shape of the nose is entirely different. and the prominent mole is not in evidence.







...........................


The Marble Bust of James Gibbs (1682 - 1754). 

Michael Rybrack.

1726.

now in the Victoria and Albert Museum.

Photograph by the author.

It is very difficult to discern any similarities with the Radcliff Camera plaster bust pictured above.



see my post - https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2015/07/a-marble-bust-of-james-gibbs.html

For Gordon Balderston's very informative Essay on the Busts of Gibbs and Alexander Pope by Rysbrack - pub. Georgian Group Journal, 2001 see -

Rysbrack's Busts of James Gibbs and Alexander Pope for Henrietta Street -

https://georgiangroup.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/GGJ_2001_01-BALDERSTON.pdf







Gibbs commissioned this bust, and it remained in his ownership until his death, another bust of Gibbs (below), also by Rysbrack, belonging to the Bodleian Library, Oxford, and now shown in the Radcliffe Camera, depicts the sitter in a more classicising mode, without a wig, and bare-chested. 


Gibbs and Rysbrack lived near one another on the Harley estate north of Oxford Street in London. They collaborated together on a number of projects, notably monuments in Westminster Abbey (designed by Gibbs, and executed by Rysbrack), and garden ornaments and sculpture for the grounds at Stowe House, Buckinghamshire.


George Vertue suggests that the working relationship between Gibbs and Rysbrack was 'not altogether happy' Gibbs employed Rysbrack 'for his own advantage not for encouragement' and speaks of 'extravagant exactions' and goes on to say 'an unreasonable griping usage to a most ingenious artist. (in his way) far more merit than Gibbs ever will be. Mr of'. Obviously Vertue was not a great fan of Mr Gibbs.


Vertue in 1723 refers to three portraits of Gibbs a 'modeld' bust suggesting a terracotta a marble bust and basso relievo with a wig on. The terracotta and basso relievo are missing.

 

In 1723 Vertue refers to a terracotta bust ' Mr Jacamo or James. Gibbs Architect born at Aberdeen. ano. 1863. his head a Moddeld by Mr Rysbrack extreamly like him a bald head. cut in marble from that another basso relievo. with a wigg on.

 

Provenance: Presented to the Church of St Martin's in the Field by William Boore an Antique dealer and silver merchant of The Strand in 1885.

Acquired by the V and A Museum in 1989.

.............


Engraved profile of James Gibbs by Bernard Baron, 

1736.


Headpiece from an unidentified publication.
10.1 x 13.0 cms 

Engraving from British Museum.
 

It is tempting to suggest that this is an engraving of the missing basso relieve by Rysbrack described by George Vertue in 1723.






....


The Radcliff Camera, Oxford  bust of James Gibbs by Michael Rysbrack.

1723.









Given its location it is very difficult to obtain good photographs of the Rysbrack Gibbs Bust.

Here are a couple of my rather feeble attempts.

Less obvious in the black and white images is the surprisingly poor quality of the marble flecked with dark inclusions











................


No sign of the mole on the left side proper of his nose!





























........................

James Gibbs.

John Michael Williams.

NPG.







Signed below his right shoulder in black: J. Williams Pinx., the J rather faint.

On the top bar of the stretcher a stencil 24 H, and in ink on a paper on the back of the centre bar: Portrait of Gibbs, the Architect, from Mr. Sharpe's Collection/I brought [edited: originally bought] from his Seat at Brockley Hill, Middx, on/the demolition of the House in [paper torn] 1830./Thomas Sharpe Smith/21 Nov. 18(40] [edited: originally (44)- the last two figures indistinct.


.........................



Portrait of James Gibbs.

John Michael Williams.

H 89.5 x W 69 cm

Bodleian Library.

Acquired prior to 1760.




.........................

James Gibbs.

Mezzotint After Wiliams.

James Mcardle.


James MacArdell (1729-1765) was born in Cow Lane, Dublin around 1729. He studied mezzotint-engraving under John Brooks. When Brooks moved to London about 1746, MacArdell and other pupils followed. 

He opened a print shop at the Golden Head Henrietta Street, Covent Garden, where in 1753 he published six views of Dublin and was a prolific engraver. He was said to be the favourite engraver of Joshua Reynolds.

MacArdell died on 2 June 1765, in his fifty-seventh year, and was buried in the churchyard at Hampstead, where a stone bore an inscription to his memory



............


James Gibbs.

McArdell after Hogarth.

Mezzotint.

British Museum.












........................



James Gibbs.

Engraving Bernard Baron after William Hogarth.
1747.

Image courtesy Metropolitan Museum, New York.












Another possible portrait of Gibbs.

Bartholomew Dandridge.

.....................


Whilst making comparisons of portrait paintings, engravings and busts is very dangerous.


Here is my suggestion for a possible candidate for the sitter. Whilst lacking the mole and having washed his hair, this bust is much closer to the busts at the RIBA and the Radcliff Camera!


Charles Hutton (1737–1823).

Aged 85.

Marble bust.

Sebastian Gahagan (c.1778–1832) or Francis Chantry.

Gahagan 


There are conflicting entries in the Biographical Dictionary of British Sculptors.... pub Yale 2009.

Both entries under Gahagan and Chantry have the bust of Hutton at Newcastle.

in The Literary & Philosophical Society of Newcastle.


Charles Hutton (1737–1823) | Art UK


NPG website says - "Marble bust by Sebastian Gahagan, with loose drapery (see NPG 5783). Newcastle Literary & Philosophical Society. 

Commissioned by subscription for the sitter who bequeathed it to the Society. 

Exhibited RA 1822 (1034). Engraved J. Thomson 1823 from a drawing by W. Derby (European Mag.). The plaster model was completed in 1821 and the marble bust presented to the sitter on 21 September 1822. Casts were obtained by ‘many of Dr. Hutton’s friends, and still continue to be supplied by the sculptor’ (Gentleman's Magazine, XCIII, 1823, I, p 232).



































https://www.british-history.ac.uk/no-series/newcastle-historical-account/pp461-486


Medallion by Wyon after the bust.

Aged 85 - as the inscription on the socle of the bust.




Engraving of the Medallion of Hutton by Wyon



.................

The Stipple Engraving of the Bust of Hutton by J Thompson.

1822



Charles Hutton was buried in the family vault at Charlton in Kent. During the last year of his life a group of his friends set up a fund to pay to have a marble bust made of him. It was executed by the sculptor Sebastian Gahagan. The subscription exceeded the amount necessary, and a medal was also produced, engraved by Benjamin Wyon, showing Hutton’s head on one side and emblems representing his discoveries about the force of gunpowder, and the density of the earth on the other

........................


Thomas Banks (1735 - 1805).

Self Portrait.

Marble Herm Bust.

1791.

see my post https://english18thcenturyportraitsculpture.blogspot.com/2019/01/bust-of-roubiliac-or-not.html

This bust has disappeared. I would dearly like to find it.

https://www.royalacademy.org.uk/art-artists/work-of-art/self-portrait-bust-of-thomas-banks-r-a





.........................


Another earlier Herm bust - Edward Thurlow, Baron Thurlow.

John Charles Felix Rossi

Artificial stone bust, 

1809.

20 in. (508 mm) high.

Purchased, 1979.

Primary Collection

NPG 5238

https://www.npg.org.uk/collections/search/portrait/mw06346/Edward-Thurlow-Baron-Thurlow?LinkID=mp07496&role=art&rNo=1&mode=test