Thursday, 9 January 2025

The portraits of Anne Seymour Damer compared with (perhaps not so) Anonymous Bust by Joseph Nollekens.

 


Post in preparation.


Comparing the Anonymous Bust, here suggested as the Amateur Sculptor Anne Seymour Damer (1749 - 1828) by Joseph Nollekens (1737 – 1823) with known painted portraits of Mrs Damer by Contemporary Artists.


It is dangerous to make these comparisons - one can never be 100% sure, even with inscribed painted portraits and busts but in this instance I intend to make the case, as best as I can, that this bust is most likely a bust of Anne Seymour Damer by Joseph Nollekens sculpted in the late 1770’s or early 1780’s.


Portrait of Mrs Damer by Angelica Kaufmann

This portrait was painted in London in 1766 when the sitter was aged 16.







___________________


Comparing the bust with The Yale Centre for British Art portrait of Mrs Damer aged 24, by Sir Joshua Reynolds 1773.

This is probably the primary version – there is another “studio of portrait at the NPG in London. 

  "Ditto [a lady], half length" [1773, Royal Academy of Arts, London, exhibition catalogue]  

https://collections.britishart.yale.edu/catalog/tms:1361

This might be wishful thinking on behalf of the Yale cataloguer.


 


The YCBA Portrait by Joshua Reynolds.




The National Portrait Gallery (London) version



-------------------------


The Uffizi Gallery, Florence self-portrait marble bust of Mrs Anne Seymour Damer.

 Presented to the Gallery by Mrs Damer in 1784 not 1778 as often repeated.

Without being too critical there is a certain generalised sameness, and a lack of definition about her portrait busts which were excused as "an adherence to the Greek style" as recommended by Joshua Reynolds.






...........................................


The Bust compared with a Miniature Portrait of Anne Seymour Damer.

She is dressed in a fanciful Elizabethan Costume initialled R C – Richard Cosway.

Height 60 mm - National Portrait Gallery - they say 1785 without providing any evidence. I suspect slightly earlier.







........................................


The possible portrait of Mrs Damer by Joshua Reynolds.

Where is it now??

The Portrait illustrated below was used on the cover of Mrs D The Life of Anne Damer 1748 - 1828 by Richard Webb pub. Brewin Books 2013.  An excellent place to start when researching Mrs Damer.

It should be read alongside Percy Nobles work of 1908 and the thesis by Benforado

 This portrait is titled "Mrs Damer dressed as Athenais in the Richmond House Players production of Theodosius" by Joshua Reynolds - 1788.

 I can find no reference to this portrait in the standard reference works on Reynolds except in the 1899 work A History of the Works of Sir Joshua Reynold by Algernon Graves and William Vine Cronin -available online at - https://archive.org/details/historyofworksof01grav/page/n13/mode/2up?view=theater&q=Damer

Iit is described as  Half length, canvas 29 x 24 in.

Full face ; cloak trimmed with ermine, and fastened with jewels at the sleeves ; low-necked dress ; pearls in hair.

 Sold by Henry Graves and Co., 1890, to Sir John Pender ; it was purchased at his sale by Messrs. Shepherd Bros., who sold it in 1898 to Charles Sedelmeyer, of Paris, the present owner.

 - therefore  the attribution should be treated with some caution until confirmed.




........................


The Bust compared with a miniature portrait of Mrs Damer by John Smart (1741 – 1811).

 – undated. 

Height 62 mm – 1770’s. 

Image courtesy Messrs Christie's.

https://www.christies.com/en/lot/lot-603686




.....................


Comparing the Bust with the Portrait of Mrs Damer by George Romney -

Mrs Damer sat to Romney six times in 1779, April 21, 24, May 24, 31, June 5, and 9th. 

She was aged 30. 

For me this and the Reynolds portraits are probably the most convincing visual evidence.



.......................

A Crop from the Waldegrave Portrait of Horace Walpole and Mrs Damer 

by Nathaniel Dance Holland. C. 1775 – 1780.

Note the shape of the ear.





__________________


The Schiavonetti Stipple Engraving.

undated.

after Richard Cosway (1742 - 1821).

Proof before letters 1791. 

I have been unable to locate the original drawing but suspect it was probably completed some 10 years earlier.

https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/P_1875-0814-1243 for another later version see https://id.rijksmuseum.nl/200251616

Richard Cosway.

He was baptised in Devon, November 5, 1742 and died London, July 4, 1821.

 Cosway is best known for his miniatures and drawings, as well as his connections to the Prince of Wales (later George IV) and fashionable Georgian society.

From the 1760s through the 1770s he exhibited consistently at the Society of Arts, the Free Society of Artists, and the Royal Academy. 

By 1785 he began to sign his works Primarius Pictor Serenissimi Walliae Principis ("Principal painter to his most serene Prince of Wales"). 

He also collected Old Master paintings, drawings, and decorative art objects, which were sold at his death by his wife, Maria, who was also an artist.










___________________

Comparing the Bust with another undated Cosway sketch of Mrs Damer in the Huntington Library. 

Pencil wash and Gouache

12.1 x 7.6cm

https://emuseum.huntington.org/objects/324/anne-seymour-damer?ctx=b7374cc6d617e9479e0716e85ca7b091420c58e0&idx=2



It should perhaps be pointed out that in my opinion Cosway uses the device of slightly enlarging the eyes in his female portraits in order to make them appear more appealing. 

This sketch or a version of it was probably that used to create the Schiavonetti stipple engraving (above).










_________________




Comparing the anonymous marble bust with the Packington Hall marble bust of Louisa Thynne (d.1832) wife of the 4th Earl of Aylesford. 

by Joseph Nollekens.

Signed and Dated 1784 (this needs to be confirmed).

I am very grateful to Lady Guernsey for providing me with these photographs


The Biographical Dictionary of British Sculptors, Pub Yale. 2009 say the bust of Louisa was exhibited at the Royal Academy in 1784.



A version of the Nollekens bust of  the  Lady Aylesford was offered for sale lot 23, 3 July 1823 at the Nollekens sale. The Catalogue does not make clear the material.

Currently the position of the bust, on top of a doorcase at Packington make photography rather difficult – I have an invitation to visit Packington in early 2025.


















........................


The Paul Mellon Photographic Archive Image of Louisa Thynne.

When searching for images of Nollekens busts using the eared support to the socle I came across this image which more or less confirmed the attribution of the (so far until then anonymous) bust to Nollekens. 

Comparisons with how the socle and eared support joined the bust itself confirmed the attribution and comparisons with the hairstyle confirmed the rough dating.





............................

Louisa Thynne, Lady Aylesford.

Mezzotint Valentine Green. 

After Joshua Reynolds.





Tuesday, 7 January 2025

A Very Fine Marble Bust of a Lady here attributed to Joseph Nollekens.

  


The Fine Marble bust of a Lady.

The bust is not signed or dated.

This post makes the suggestion that the bust is of The Honourable Anne Seymour Damer.

by Joseph Nollekens (1737- 1823), of circa 1784.


Some weeks ago I was asked by Milo Dickinson managing director fine art dealers  Dickinson of Jermyn Street, London to research the identity and origin of a very fine but anonymous bust which lacked any inscription then in their possession. The bust is now in a private collection.

As anyone familiar with this blog will know my main field of interest is in mid 18th Century English portrait sculpture but that my researches take me down the highways and byways of English sculpture from the 16th and into the 19th century.

https://www.simondickinson.com/


In my opinion this bust is true masterpiece of English portrait sculpture and I feel so lucky and privileged to have become involved with it. Thank you very much Milo Dickinson.

The quality is superb and the original surface appears to have survived unblemished and more importantly uncleaned - retaining its original polished surface and is the product of a master at the height of his powers.

I have written at some length on English sculpture and in particular portrait busts - in particular those of the two most important masters of the mid 18th Century Louis Francois Roubiliac and Michael Rysbrack and have touched on the slightly later works of  Joseph Wilton, and Thomas Banks but have only touched on Nollekens

It is very unusual for such an high quality sculpture to remain undocumented, unmolested, hidden and unrecognised for over two hundred years - 


The bust was purchased at the sale by Nigel Ward & Co Auctioneers of Pontrilas of the private collection of  The Right Honourable Lord Peter Wynford Innes Rees Q.C. (d.2008) of Goytre Hall near Abergavenny, Monmouthshire. He was the son of Thomas Wynford (Dagger) Rees (d. 1959) who in turn was born in Anglesey the son of TM Rees a Welsh non conformist who was minister Bethel Welsh Wesleyan Chapel at Barry, South Glamorgan

The house is 16th Century with Edwardian additions. It would appear that the house was purchased by Thomas Wynford Rees in 1948.

Given this provenance it is most unlikely that the bust came down through the family but was perhaps purchased as an anonymous bust at one of the many break up sales of country houses after the Second World War.


I am very grateful to Milo Dickinson for allowing me to post this research and for providing the photographs.
























































.....................


Detail of the Socle and Eared Support to the Bust.

With the slightly convex or serpentine eared support typical of  many of Nollekens earlier busts - the use this form of support is peculiar to Nollekens based on classical precedents mualso much employed by Nollekens' master in Rome Bartolemeo Cavaceppi - he appears to have stopped using this form of support for his busts  after about 1800.

See my previous  post which details the earlier Nollekens busts using the eared support on the socle- https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2024/11/some-earlier-nollekens-busts.html






Friday, 3 January 2025

Anne Seymour Damer 1748 - 1828. Timeline and some thoughts on the Nollekens bust at the Rhode Island School of Design Museum after Mrs Damer.

 



Mrs Anne Seymour Damer. nee Conway

A very Rough Timeline - Post in preparation.

Born 1748. Died 1828.

The main thrust here is to examine the movements of Mrs Damer and how they might have coincided with other sculptors of the period including Giuseppi Ceracchi (1751 - 1802), John Bacon I (1740 - 1799)both of whom were believed to have taught her and in particular Joseph Nollekens who copied one of her busts suggested here as a self portrait.

A real problem here is that Mrs Damer requested that all her paperwork to be destroyed after her death and so all information, except for a couple of exceptions, on her life has to be derived from secondary sources.


1748. Born 


1763, 1 May HW wrote to Damers father "Good night to the infanta.. whose progress in waxen statuary is advancing so fast that by next winter she may rival (Benjamin) Rackstrow's old man".

1766. Anne Conway was painted by Angelica Kauffman in 1766, the year in which she made the decision to move from Italy to England. Within a month of having arrived in London Kauffman was hard at work on this portrait. On 2nd August Lady Mary Coke wrote to her sister, the Countess of Stafford:

"I went to Lady Ailesbury’s, and found her and Mr Conway were going to a painter who had just arrived from Italy, and was brought over by Lady Wentworth, the same who drew a picture of Mr Garrick, which was shown, I am told, in the exhibition. I went with them, and saw the picture she was painting of Miss Conway. It was like, and appeared to be to be well done, but too large, as you would take for a very big woman".


1767, 15 June, Anne Conway marries John Damer. Eldest son of Lord Milton.

1772. Joseph Nollekens became a Royal Academician in 1772, soon after his return from Rome, and Council minutes record his conscientious attendance. Giuseppi Angelini (1742 - 1811).arrives shortly afterwards to work as his assistant

1773. Giuseppi Ceracchi (1751 - 1801) arrives in London. He exhibited busts at the R.A. from 1776 - 79. He worked under Agostino Carlini (d.1790 first recorded in England in1760) and lodged at his house near at Kings Square Court, Soho Square. 

In October 1773 Richard Hayward recorded in his list of British visitors to Rome that ‘Giuseppe Carachi Italian sculptor’ had come to England.

JT Smith in Nollekens and his Times . 1828 records - "when was taken to see him,  ....very extensive premises at No. 76,  Margaret-street,  Cavendish-square.

JT Smith who noted that Ceracchi ‘was the Honourable Mrs Damer’s master in Nollekens... Vol II p. 120.as that lady declared to me herself.’


The Monument by Carlini to commemorate his wife Caroline, was commissioned by Joseph Damer (father in law of Mrs Damer) in 1775 which stands in the north transept of Milton Abbey in Dorset. Whilst coincidental it is possible that Ceracchi was working as Carlini's assistant, thus the connection between Mrs Damer and Ceracchi.

See - Championing Liberty: The Roman Sculptor Giuseppe Ceracchi in Britain and in America, by Karin Wolfe  pub 2018 Page 195. available on line      https://accademiasanluca.it/uploads/American_Latium_df4004c1dc.pdf

On the other hand Walpole may have been responsible for introducing Ceracchi to his protégé, Anne Seymour Damer. Apparently smitten by her ‘graceful nymph-like person’ the Italian ‘begged her to sit to him, and he made a most charming statue of her, whole length as large as life, in terracotta’ (Anecdotes 1937, 142). 

This was later translated to marble (by Westmacott?) and is one of Ceracchi’s most inventive compositions. Damer is depicted as a personification of sculpture, standing with her tools at her feet and a statuette of a river god in her hands (2).

 Damer, who had previously only sculpted portrait profiles in wax, subsequently received ‘two or three lessons’ in modelling from Ceracchi, after which she began to work in terracotta (Anecdotes 1937, 142).



1776. Suicide of husband John Damer (b.1744) who shot himself at the Bedford Arms, Covent Garden.

1778/9. Mrs Damer travels to Florence. Little is known about this trip, 13 September 79 Horace Walpole tells her father "you may imagine how happy I am at Mrs D's return....

1780, February, Giuseppi Ceracchi disposes of his premises in Margaret St and leaves England.


1780. Terracotta Bust of Niobe (or Niobid).  Her first attempt (HW) at making a bust, size 47 cms. signed and dated Anna Damer 1780, Fecit.1781/82. She was in Florence on 21 November, in Rome from late Nov 71 - April 72, returning via Venice 5th May, and Paris, back in England 13 June.

Walpole wrote to Horace Mann in Florence that she was so reserved and modest that ‘we have by accident discovered that she writes Latin like Pliny and is learning Greek. In Italy she will be a prodigy; she models like Bernini, has excelled the moderns in the similitudes of her busts and has lately begun one in marble.’ This probably refers to the Niobid.


1781 - Ceracchi returns to Rome.

1781/82. To Italy with Lady William Campbell, (widow of Lord William Campbell). to Naples, arrived in Florence in early November 71 departed for Rome on 21 Nov. 


William Hamilton writes to Horace Walpole on 28 May 1782 referring to her bust of Ceres, taken from a "Sicilian" medallion (disappeared). Mentioned in a letter from WH to HW 25 Feb 1783 regarding a cast sent to Princess Dashkova.


1783. Sculpts a profile medallion of  the daughter of Princess Dashkova, perhaps from a sitting of 1781 when Dashkova was in London.


1784. The Portland Stone Thames and Isis Keystones for the bridge at Henley.

1785/6. To Italy - Departing England 30 October, Florence early 1786;  in Rome by 24 Jan 86; Naples March/April. Rome in May, Florence 1 Jun; back in England July.

Almost certainly Damer presents the marble self portrait busts to the Uffizi and not in 1778/9 as some authorities suggest.

1785 Walpole records she made a ‘Bust of her mother Lady Ailesbury in terra-cotta, veiled.’


1787. George III statue for the Records House, Edinburgh.

1789. Marble bust of her mother Caroline Campbell, Lady Ailsbury.

1797. When Horace Walpole died in 1797, he left a life interest in Strawberry Hill to Damer. She had the job of recording the contents of Strawberry Hill for the Berry family, who had moved into an adjoining property. Anne used Strawberry Hill as her country house until 1811, which she maintained alongside her central London home in Upper Brook Street. In 1818, she returned to Twickenham, buying York House.


.............................


The Nollekens Marble Bust.

Inscribed Nollekens Ft from a Model by the Hon Mrs Damer.

Rhode Island School of Design.

It is described as Head of a Woman but I would suggest that it is perhaps a copy of a self portrait bust by Mrs Damer of c. 1784 - 86.

It has been suggested that it is the missing bust of Elizabeth Duchess of Devonshire by Mrs Damer.


Elizabeth Christiana Hervey was baptised on 13 May 1758 in Horringer, Suffolk, the daughter of Frederick Hervey and Elizabeth Davers. 

The family moved to Ireland when Hervey was appointed Bishop of Cloyne (1767) and then Bishop of Derry (1768) through the influence of his brother. Elizabeth, known as Bess, spent her childhood in relative poverty, in Ireland and on the continent. 

The family fortunes changed drastically when Hervey became 4th Earl of Bristol in December 1779, but by this time, Bess was already married.

 

 

 A short-lived marriage - on 16 December 1776, Bess married John Foster, an Irish MP. She had two sons, Frederick (1777) and Augustus (1780), but the marriage was not a success and in 1780, the couple separated. 

Mr Foster was unfaithful, but on her side, Bess may have been regretting marriage to someone beneath her newly elevated status as Lady Elizabeth Foster. Elizabeth gave up custody of her sons to Foster and returned to England, where she was forced to live in reduced circumstances.

In May 1782, Bess met the Duke and Duchess of Devonshire in Bath, and quickly became Georgiana's closest friend. From this time, she lived in a triad with Georgiana and her husband, William, the 5th Duke of Devonshire, for about 25 years. She bore two illegitimate children by the Duke: a daughter, Caroline St Jules, and a son, Augustus (later Augustus Clifford, 1st Baronet), who were raised at Devonshire House with the Duke's legitimate children by Georgiana. Georgiana grew ill and died in 1806; three years later, Bess married the duke and became the Duchess of Devonshire. He died two years later.



Unfortunately it is not dated.

This bust presents several questions.

Who does it represent?

When was it sculpted?

Why would Nollekens make this bust? Did he have any interaction with Mrs Damer.

Why did Nollekens reproduce the sketchy finish of this bust particularly with the hair?

Where was it before it went to Rhode Island?



























.........................


The Rhode Island Marble Bust on the left and the Uffizi Self Portrait Marble Bust Compared.

The Biographical Dictionary. Yale, 2009 under the entry for Damer records: -

1778 (this is incorrect - it should be 1784) - The Uffizi self portrait - and other versions?

1785, Self portrait - mentioned in Walpole Correspondence Vol 12 page 272.

1786, Self Portrait - Accademia di San Luca - Neoclassicism 1972 page 230.

Unless the 1786 entry refers to the Uffizi bust it would appear that there were two and possibly three variants of the Damer self portrait


The difficulty here is that the features of her female busts are very generalised. The bust of her mother (1789). Elizabeth Farren  (Countess of Derby (NPG) c. 1788, and Mrs Freeman as Isis (V and A) all have similar generalised features.

As I have stated in previous posts it is very dangerous to make these sorts of comparisons - all I can do here is present the visual evidence as best as I can -I leave the reader to make up their own minds!





........................


The Rhode Island Marble Bust on the left and the Portrait Marble Bust of Elizabeth Farren compared.

Whilst the noses are different the rest of the features of these two busts are remarkably similar.




......................


The Statue of Mrs Damer from an original Terracotta by Ceracchi at the British Museum.

 Height: 181 centimetres Length: 59 centimetres (plinth). Depth: 46 centimetres.

The original terracotta of 1778 was modelled by Ceracchi, but I suggest that the marble was carved in the studio of Westmacott.


Note from the BM website "The attribution to Westmacott  was no longer current by 1932 when the disposal of the statue was discussed, and agreed on, by the Trustees (see above). As the attribution was made in Westmacott's lifetime (see above), given his close association with the Museum, it is just possible that the statue may have been carved in his workshop, but convincing proof of this has yet to be found".

The Westmacott attribution comes from several sources including - 

Old and New London, Walter Thornbury, pub 1878 ref BM  "Against the wall, near the foot of the stairs, is a statue, executed by Westmacott, of the Hon. Mrs. Damer". 


Given to the BM by Lord Frederick Campbell.

As the donor died in 1816, the work must have been donated before this date, but no record has so far been found. Lord Frederick Campbell was the sitter's uncle, and may have had the statue carved from the model, according to Smith, 1828 (see Dawson 1999, p. 89). 

A terracotta was recorded in 1989?, but its present whereabouts is unknown.

https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/H_OA-10540


see -  Portrait Sculpture, a Catalogue of the British Museum Collection, c. 1675-1975, Aileen Dawson pub 1999 / (27).









...............................


I intend to put together a brief piece on Italian sculptors working in England in the 18th and early 19th centuries sometime shortly.

Plura, Carlini, Ceracchi, Locatelli, Turnerelli, (Tognarelli) etc.



Monday, 30 December 2024

George III by Mrs Damer, Edinburgh and some more sculptural portraits.

 


Post in preparation

George III.

Mrs Anne Seymour Damer.

Marble Statue.

Register House Edinburgh.

1787.

Images below courtesy the Art UK website.

George III (1738–1820) | Art UK


Lord Frederick Campbell (1729 -1816) Mrs Damer’s maternal uncle, had, as Lord Clerk Register of Scotland, been instrumental in securing the appointment of Robert and James Adam as Architects  of the new Register House in Edinburgh the first purpose built public records office in England.

Donated by Mrs Damer


it is possibly based on a similarly posed full length figure of George I which was put up in 1718 with a series of statues in the Courtyard of the Royal Exchange. McLintock states that it was never intended to be a true likeness rather an idealised representation of "the Majesty of Kingship".


Is it me? - I can find no resemblance!! I am posting some further images of busts of George III for comparison.

For a very informative article by John McLintock in the January 2010 issue of the Burlington Magazine see -

https://issuu.com/burlington/docs/1282burlingtonjan2010


In my opinion most references to this statue brush over the nepotism and amateurism involved in the creation  and installation of this work

































































































...............................


For Comparison.

The Society of Antiquaries Marble Bust of George III.

John Bacon.