Tuesday, 1 July 2025

The Busts of Dr Matthew Lee and John Belchier - Roubiliac.

 


This post under construction

I first posted on the bust of Lee July 2017.

https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/07/bust-of-dr-matthew-lee-by-roubiliac.html


This was the first published essay on the subject of this bust - peculiarly it is not recorded in the Dictionary of Sculptors in Britain .. Roscoe et al, pub Yale 2009.

Mrs Esdaile states in Roubiliac, Oxford 1928  'placed on a bracket below the gallery of the college Laboratory... is thickly covered in paint which effectually prevents the search for a signature'.

Currently at the foot of the staircase in the Lee Building, the former Anatomy School, Christ Church College, Oxford now the Senior Common Room.

 

Placed in the building in 1758 (info from A Christchurch Miscellany, Hiscock, 1946).

This bust went unnoticed by Mrs Poole until she was alerted to it by Mrs Katherine Arundell Esdaile

see page 317, Catalogue of Portraits Oxford... Vol III, Mrs Reginald Lane Poole, 1925.

 

Noted in the lecture room in 1925, now in the hallway on the ground floor.

Mrs Poole says the bust was painted but I am informed there is no obvious evidence.

The bust is very dirty and could do with a gentle wash.

I suspect that neither ladies actually examined this bust.


...................

 A few unedited notes on Dr Lee.

 

 

Matthew Lee born in Northamptonshire matriculated in 1713 and studied medicine, graduating BA (1717), MA (1720), BM (1722) and DM (1726). He showed marked affection for the House, and the Chapter leased to him the lucrative tithes of the Rectory of Chippenham, which  no doubt secured his material comfort, since the tithes were additional to the income from his rewarding and extensive medical practices.

 

Candidate for the Royal College of Physicians on 12 April 1731, became a Fellow on 3 April 1732

 

Having married a young lady from London in 1730, he moved to the capital, where he practised even more successfully. Lee does not at this stage appear to have had great interest in the scientific aspects of the profession; his contribution was to come later, in his will.

 

Matthew Lee was a Westminster School and Christ Church physician, who graduated MB in 1722, delivered the Bodleian oration in 1723, and received his DM in 1726.

 

He lived in part of Frewin's house in New Inn Hall Street, so probably gained his clinical practice with him. However, when James Keill died in 1719, he left Lee his microscope and all his medical books, and as Lee was a Northampton man, he may have studied with Keill as well.

 

Dr Lee moved to London in 1730, became a fellow of the College of Physicians and Harveian orator, and succeeded Noel Broxholme as physician to Frederick Prince of Wales, but neither he nor Sir Edward Wilmot recognised the gravity of the Prince's fatal illness. Prince Frederick died in 1751 from an infected cyst possibly initiated two years previously by a blow from a cricket ball.

 

It is thought that the creation of the Anatomy Laboratory had originally been suggested by John Freind, physician to Queen Caroline, who gave a course in Chemistry in 1704.  His will directed that, if his son should die without children, £1000 would be given for the building of an Anatomy School at Christ Church and for the salary of a Reader in the subject. It is not clear what happened to this benefaction but the son died unmarried in 1750 and it is probable that the bequest was indeed made to Christ Church, since 1750 is the commonly quoted date of the foundation of the Matthew Lee Readership (the Freind bequest would in any case have been inadequate for the purpose intended).

 

This bequest was later augmented by some £10,000 by Matthew Lee.

 

Matthew Lee died in 1755 and left the bulk of his estate (over £20,000) to Christ Church for the advancement of Westminster students and for the endowment of a Readership in Anatomy.

 

 Nevertheless, there were strict conditions: the holder of the post was to have been educated at Westminster, to hold the degree of MA having studied physick, to be a layman, to reside in Oxford for at least six months annually, to instruct only in Anatomy, Physick and Botany, and to dissect two bodies each year (for which the Trust provided an additional £40 per annum as running costs). The dissections were public spectacles: the Dean could nominate four Students and two Commoners to attend without charge, all others being required to pay a fee.

 

 Dr Lee's  Readership of Anatomy was established in 1767 at Christ Church College, Oxford


https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2018/07/bust-of-dr-matthew-lee-by-roubiliac.html

































....................



The Bust of John Belchier at the Royal College of Surgeons Lincolns Inn Fields.












....................


I have touched on the subject previously but it is worthwhile returning, of Roubiliac using the same bust or upper part of the body on different busts.

As far as I can tell this method of duplicating the upper part of the torso is unique to Roubiliac.

Here are couple more examples -

Nicholas Hawksmoor 

Plaster Bust.

In the buttery at All Souls College Oxford





The Marble Bust of Thomas Missing,

on the Monument to him in the Church at Wootton St Lawrence, nr Basingstoke







............................

Anonymous Lead Bust.

Victoria and Albert Museum.

Here attributed to Roubiliac





The Marble Bust of James Lawes.

It is inscribed by John Cheere and dated 1737.

on the Monument  in St Andrew Parish Church. Halfway Tree, Kingston, Jamaica.

This is the only bust inscribed by either Henry or John Cheere.

John Cheere also inscribes the monument to the mother in law of James Lawes in St Peters Parish Church, Vere, Jamaica.

The Monument to Mrs Deborah Gibbons (nee Favell) d . 1711.

Mother of  Elizabeth Lawes later Home, Countess of Home (née Gibbons; 1703/04 – 15 January 1784).

The monument is inscribed by John Cheere and was ordered by Elizabeth Lawes perhaps at the same time as that of her husband in 1737.

see my previous post - https://bathartandarchitecture.blogspot.com/2025/04/a-monument-inscribed-by-john-cheere-in.html

For Monuments in the West Indies see -

https://ia601306.us.archive.org/20/items/monumentalinscri00lawrrich/monumentalinscri00lawrrich.pdf











........................
 

A reduced version of the V and A and Aires Busts

The Kirkleatham Plaster Bust of Congreve.

The Bronzed Plaster Bust of William Congreve supplied by John Cheere to Chomley Turner of  Kirkleatham Hall, Yorkshire in 1749.

 Now with York Museums.

 Height 16.75"

There is another version of this bust at Blair Castle described as






.................................



Sir Andrew Fountaine.

Terracotta.

Norwich Castle Museum.





..................


Thomas Winnington (d.1746).

Stanford on Teme. Worcester.








................


The Bamber Monument.

Barking.





..............

The Three Busts of Jonathan Tyers, John Ray and Henry Streatfield.





Jonathan Tyers.

Terracotta.

Victoria and Albert Museum

A Marble bust of Tyers  was Lot 77 - Sotheby's 24 June 1927.

The marble bust is now in Birmingham Museums Stores.


This terracotta and the marble version in the Birmingham Museum were almost certainly commissioned by Tyers himself.  These two busts were recorded in the possession of the Tyers's grandson, and then passed by descent to the Reverend Jonathan Tyers Barrett of Brandon House, Suffolk.

 The busts were sold at the Brandon House sale in September 1919.

 The purchaser at this sale was Mr R. Levine of Norwich, whose son, Mr G. J. Levine, sold the terracotta to the V&A in 1927 for £50.

 The marble bust was sold at Sotheby's on 24 June 1927 (lot 77), but in 1956 it was acquired by the Birmingham City Museum and Art Gallery from Sabin, a London dealer. (probably Frank Sabin).







John Ray.

Terracotta British Museum.


For the marble in the Wren Library Trinity College Cambridge see -







A Second Terracotta Bust of Ray was offered for sale by Sotheby's London  - Lot 65 - 5 July 1990.

This bust has the fur collar.

 Presumably it was unsold - it appears again on the market Lot 145 22 April 1993.

 Inscribed under the right shoulder Roubiliac Sc.

 It would be useful to inspect this bust - It is possible that it is a finished prototype for the marble but on the other hand I suspect that it might be another cast from the original marble at the Wren Library.

 Where is it now?




...............


The Marble bust of Ray in the Wren Library.

with the added detail of the fur collar.








Henry Streatfield.

Terracotta.

in the Streatfield Mausoleum at Chiddingstone, Kent.




Sunday, 29 June 2025

Three Henry Cheere Monuments at Winchester Catherdral, Old Alresford Hants and Fifehead Magdalen, Dorset and some comparable examples.

 


.

These three remarkable monuments by Henry Cheere each deserve a post of their own.


This post is a series of notes and the subject of Cheere's monuments will need a more thorough investigation. 

All three monuments are notable for the extremely fine quality of the carving, the excellence of the design and the use of the rare and expensive veneers of Sicilian Jaspar and Brocatella marbles.

All photographs taken by the Author.

Cheeres workshops were in Westminster - his residence was in old Palace Yard - it is not yet clear to me whether he had separate workshops at Millbank - only a couple of hundred yards away - but the closeness to the Wharfs of the marble importers - the Wallingers, Chapman Birds and latterly the Del Medicos which gave easy access to the exotic marbles that were a feature of his monuments.


The Monument to Dean Thomas Cheyne (d.1760) in Winchester Cathedral,

 the monument to Jane First Lady Rodney (d. 1757) at Old Alresford, Hants.

and the Newman Family Monument in the Newman Chapel at Fifehead Magdalen, North Dorset.

...............

1. Monument to Dean Thomas Cheyne (d 1760).

Designed by Henry Cheere.

Winchester Cathedral.

Photographed by the Author.

This is one of a group of monuments of similar design from the Westminster workshop of Henry Cheere.


For the shear exuberance of the carving and the use of the coloured marble there is little to equal it.

The full flowering of the Rococo in a Church Monument.

The monument to Katherine Lewis at Chalgrove, Oxfordshire of 1766, although not as ornate has a similar conformation with the two seated figures and a background veneered with Sicilian Jaspar.

(see the rather poor image below - to be updated when the opportunity arises). 

The Wyntle monument at Merton College Chapel whilst less exuberant also uses the same basic conformation with the two mourning female figures either side of the sarcophagus. It also features the Pheonix rising from the flames at the top.

but very much influenced by the monument to Katherine Bovey in Westminster Abbey - designed by James Gibbs and sculpted by Michael Rysbrack. 1727.











The Iconography on the central relief here should be compared with the Roubiliac Monument to Mary Myddleton (1688 - 1747) at Wrexham. With the broken pyramid and the figure rising from the sarcophagus at the last trump.













































..........................

The Monument to Lucy Skipwith.

St. Wilfred's Church, Metheringham. Lincolnshire 

A few miles south of Lincoln.

1763.

This monument has direct parallels with that of John Yate at St Mary the Virgin at Arlingham, Glouc.
in particular the relief of Hope which follows the duplicates the design.

see my recent post - 


Image  and info from


I cannot recommend this website highly enough to anyone interested in locating monuments in Lincolnshire - if only every county had such a resource













..................


The Monument to Katherine Villiers Lewis (1724 - 13 April 1756).

Wife of the Rev John Lewis from 1755 Dean of Ossory in Ireland.

1756.

Daughter of the Rev. George Villiers (1690 - 1748) vicar of Chalgrove he inherited the title of  Earl of Buckingham but never used it.

They married 7 Nov 1747 at St Margaret's Westminster.

Mar. Lie. Pac. , 26 Oct. 1747 for John Lewis, of Dartford, Kent. Clerk. and Catherine Villiers, of St Margaret's, Westminster, both single and aged above 21.—He was elected to Oxford from St. Peter's College. Westminster, and matriculated from Christ Church 12 June 1734,' 17, as son of John of London. Esq., and was B.A.24 API. M.A. 1740-1. 

He became Rector of Dartford, Kent. ib 1747. but resigned in 1755, and was instituted Dean of Ossory, in Ireland, 24 May in the latter year. He married a second wife, and died 28 June 1783.



The Parish Church of St Mary the Virgin, Chalgrove, Oxfordshire: 

Of tangential interest - the Wall paintings at Chalgrove - this monument obscures part of some very interesting 14th century wall paintings.

https://www.oxoniensia.org/volumes/2009/oakes.pdf

https://chalgrovechurch.org/visiting/heritage/
























..............

The Wyntle Monument.

1750.

Merton College.

University of Oxford.

A slightly more restrained version of the design of the monuments above from the workshop of Henry Cheere.

Robert Wyntle was Warden  at Merton College - 1734 - 50.


Anne Wyntle was most likely born in Gloucester, where her brother was born in 1683. She died in August 1746 and was buried in the north transept of the chapel, her life marked by a monument on the west wall, among the most sensitive in the chapel. Her defining characteristic: that she was “the best of sisters” (sorori optimae). 

The registration of her burial was overlooked at the time and was only inserted later into the register, between the entries for Jane Sherwood in 1745 and that of her brother Robert in August 1750 (see below).










































https://www.merton.ox.ac.uk/library-and-archives/exhibitions/merton-women-since-1264/in-the-wardens-lodgings






Illustration from The Gentleman's Magazine, December 1789.

This would suggest that the monument never had the elaborate surrounds on the two similar monuments illustrated above.





............................


The Monument to Jane Rodney nee Compton. (1730 - 57).

Wife of George Bridges Rodney (1718 - 92). Rear Admiral of the Blue.

She died in childbirth, aged 27 leaving two young sons.

St Mary's Church. Old Alresford. Hampshire.

For an useful short biography of the family see -


This was a very difficult monument to photograph - the light was very low and I had no access to stepladders etc.

The monument is very dirty - I would advise a gentle wash with a little dilute Fairy Liquid.

I suspect that the staining of the bust has been caused by a liberal application of bird or bat poo in the past.




























































...................................


The Westminster Abbey Monument to Katherine Bovey.

Michael Rysbrack designed by James Gibbs.




A Book of Architecture, containing Designs of Buildings and Ornaments. By James Gibbs pub. 1728.

p. 115.






____________________________



The Monument to Sir Richard Newman and his family.

c.1750.

This monument (and in particular the portrait busts) deserves a post to itself and I will return to it in the future.

Designed by Henry Cheere.

St Mary Magdalen Parish Church, Fifehead Magdalen. North Dorset.

As in most of my posts regarding Henry Cheere - I have to voice my suspicions that Henry Cheere whilst a very good designer and consummate business man, not to say social climber, was not the actual sculptor of many of the works that are attributed to him but employed a large workshop in Palace Yard, Westminster and also subcontracted much of the work - it appears that Thomas and Benjamin Carter provided much of the decorative elements of his chimneypieces.

 Am I doing Henry Cheere a disservice - was he a great portrait sculptor as well as a designer of funeral monuments and architectural features? - As I put more time into the works particularly the monuments the picture should become clearer research continues!

The Biographical Dictionary of British Sculptors... pub Yale 2009.

In my opinion the three busts were carved by a different hand to the reliefs which don't quite exhibit the same degree of skill.

The Monument was restored by Sally Strachey Historic Conservation.


Sally Strachey's report states -

"The inscription was originally carved with the dates of the daughters’ deaths empty. These were then carved in as each one passed away. In total there are four letter cutters hands at work here. With the letter cutting being light, the monument was in place when this was done" 

For an in depth report on this monument see -




This is the last and by far the grandest of the Newman monuments in the Newman chapel which was installed around 1750 to commemorate Sir Richard Newman (1676 - 1721) and family - 

his wife Frances (nee Samwell: d. 1730).

his son Sir Samwell Newman (b.c1696 -1747) who never married and died intestate. 

and his three daughters: Frances (d. 1775), Barbara (d. 1763) and Elizabeth (d. 1774).

................



Sir Richard Newman, 1st Baronet MP. JP. DL. (c. 1675-1721), of Evercreech Park, was MP for Milborne Port in 1701.

 

 Sir Richard Newman Bt (d.1721) was the eldest son of Richard Newman (d.1695) of Evercreech Park and Fifehead. He was educated at Sherborne, and Pembroke College, Oxford.


http://newman-family-tree.net/Col-Richard-Newman-of-Fifehead.html

 On 1 June 1696 Sir Richard Newman married Frances, daughter of Sir Thomas Samwell, 1st Bt, and had three sons and four daughters.

The Newman Chapel  dates back to around 1693 when it, and the vault below, were built by Richard Newman (1620 - 1695). 


The vault below the chapel is believed to contain the remains of several members of the Newman family who lived in the long-demolished Fifehead Manor that was situated next door to the church. 

Richard's father Richard (1584-1664) and his grandfather Thomas (c.1560-1649), are memorialised on the chapel's east wall, while his son Richard (1650-1682) is memorialised on the west wall. 

On the north wall of the Newman Chapel is the magnificent monument designed Henry Cheere, and made in his Westminster workshop c. 1750.

It commemorates Richard's grandson Sir Richard Newman Bart. (1675-1721), his wife Frances and their four children.

Richard Newman is said to have taken the rank of Colonel during the English Civil War and to have assisted King Charles Il to escape capture by Cromwell's soldiers after the Battle of Worcester in 1651, however no evidence supporting either legend has been found. 

Richard Newman purchased the freehold of the Fifehead estate following the restoration of King Charles in 1660, perhaps with money received from the King as a reward for service. 

Hitherto the estate had been leased through four generations of Newmans from the Abbey of St Augustine's of Bristol over the preceding 130 years; the families connection with the village goes back much further, to a John Newman who was Rector of Fifehead from 1405 to 1408.

It is odd that the chapel's builder, Richard (1620-1695), has no memorial in his chapel. 

Some 50 years after his death, Sir Henry Cheere's grand monument was installed on the north wall, and it has been suggested that it replaced a previous monument.


..................


The Newman Family History.

For an invaluable website detailing the history of the Newmans see - http://www.newman-family-tree.net/


..........................


The Newmans in Old Palace Yard Westminster.


Henry Cheere it is believed owned a house next door to the Newman family in Old Palace Yard, Westminster and knew them well, and therefor their busts might represent accurate likenesses.

If this information is correct this house was probably taken and replaced with the Office of Ordnance put up in 1780 and removed in 1805.


There are three references to Newman properties in Westminster.

Sir William Honeywood was son-in-law to Richard Newman of Fifehead (1620-1695). 

The History of Parliament's website describes Sir William as "m. 15 July 1675, Anna Christiana (d. 1736), da. of Richard Newman of Tothill Street, Westminster and Fifehead Magdalen, Dorset". This is the only reference that places Richard in Tothill Street. Perhaps it has the name wrong and Tothill Street should read Tufton Street.

 

Richard Newman of Evercreech Park 1650 - 1682, left a will in which he stated that he will "give unto my wife Mrs Grace Newman my House in Tufton street in the City of Westminster".

 

His father Richard Newman 1620-1695 left a later will saying: "I give and bequeath unto the said Sir William Honeywood and Peter Walter and to their Executors Administrators and Assigns for and during the remainder of my tenure therein All? those? my four Messuages or Tenements with their appurtenances situated in Tufton Street in the Parish of St Margaret Westminster? in the several occupations of myself, Francis Holles Newman my son, Edward Scott my Son in Law and heretofore of one Mrs Corfe". It went on to say "I give and bequeath unto my said daughter in law Mrs Grace Newman the house wherein she now dwells situate in Tufton Street aforesaid". 

It appears from these extracts that the family possessed four (or even five) messuages or dwellings in Tufton Street.

 

Raymond Mercier also reported that Richard Newman 1620-1695 had a dwelling in Tufton Street which was probably inherited by his son. It may also have been owned by his father Richard Newman of Fifehead d.1664 since it appears to be he that is described in the purchase contract for Evercreech Park as Richard Newman of the City of Westminster. [My own view is that it was Richard (1620-1695) that purchased Evercreech Park, but I may be wrong. CJEN 2023]

 

Old Palace Yard:- In an Act of Parliament drawn up in 1754 to empower a committee of the estate of Elizabeth Kitchen to make leases during her lunacy, mentions the four children of Sir Richard Newman of Evercreech, viz: Sir Samwell, Frances, Barbara and Elizabeth, living in a tenement at the Old Palace Yard, Westminster. 

The Act describes the dwelling in quite disparaging terms: "Freehold Messuage or Tenement, in the said Parish of Saint Margaret, Westminster, is in such a decayed and ruinous State and Condition, that it will be absolutely necessary to pull down, rebuild, or substantially repair, the same: But it is apprehended, that no Person will take a Lease thereof, for the Purpose aforesaid, without having a long Term of Years granted of the said Premises."


Before the recent restoration, it was clear that the dates of the deaths of Sir Richard's three daughters were painted on? (inscribed) after the monument's completion whereas Sir Samwell's death in 1747 was recorded in the original text. It can therefore be deduced that the memorial was commissioned by one or all of the daughters sometime after the death of  Samwell in 1747 and before Barbara's death in 1763. 


The inscription was carved by a letter cutter who was not aware of the correct spelling of Samwell Newman.













......................

The Monument was erected after the death of Samwell Newman in 1747.

There seems to have been some confusion as to the identity of the male busts.

The Bust of Richard Newman (d. 1721) presumably the right hand bust.


The Bust of Samwell Newman (d. 1747) presumably the bust at the apex of the monument.


...............





The Bust of Frances Newman nee Samwell: d. 1730).

Wife of  Sir Richard Newman (1676 - 1721).

Perhaps the most impressive of the three busts - most likely carved posthumously using a portrait.


I find the temptation here is to ascribe the work to Roubiliac - probably the sculptor most adept at recreating a posthumous but very lifelike portrait. He was particularly good at creating busts of older sitters with out any idealisation.

As I have already pointed out I might be doing Henry Cheere a disservice but it is odd that no signed or inscribed bust by Henry Cheere has come to light so far.

Hopefully my photographs will go some way to illustrate the subtleties of this very beautiful bust.








































.....................





.........................



Whilst obviously very competent pieces of sculpture, particularly in the carving of the dress, it is currently my belief that these three reliefs are by a different sculptor to that of the busts and were added later.







I would suggest that the three busts were perhaps sculpted by a different and rather more accomplished hand to that of the three reliefs.

The three portrait reliefs are very unusual in that they depict the three daughters who did not die until some time after the making of the monument.


A Perhaps Related Design.

The detailing particularly that of the apron is typical of the workshop of John Cheere.

 Victoria and Albert Museum.






............


The Restoration of the Newman Monument.

Carried out in 2018.

For the excellent and comprehensive reports by Sally Strachey Historic Conservation see 








.......................

The Mural Monument to Richard Newman (d. 1664),
and  his father Thomas Newman (d.1649).

On the East Wall of the Newman Chapel.

c.1664.

Sizes - Height 135.5 cm x width 60 cm.



......................



Richard Newman (1650 - 1682).

Aged 32 - he predeceased his father Richard Newman d. 17

Restored mural monument on the West Wall of the Newman Chapel recording the removal of his leaden coffin to the vault.









............................


Fifehead Manor.

History of Dorset. pub 1870. p58 notes that "The Mansion, in part taken down about 1806 and the remainder converted into a farm house, was perhaps situated in as pleasant a spot as any in the county of Dorset, on a gentle eminence surrounded by avenues of lofty elms, commanding on the east a picturesque view of Stour Provost